Old Carolina Barbecue Company Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Old Carolina Barbecue Company, where the heart of Southern barbecue meets the warmth of genuine service. Nestled in Massillon, OH, this establishment offers a mouthwatering menu that delights every palate. Customers rave about the tender pulled pork and the unforgettable half slab of ribs that boast unique flavors elevating the barbecue experience. Signature dishes include the smoky baked beans and zesty coleslaw, perfect complements to any meal.
What truly sets Old Carolina apart is the exceptional service. From the friendly staff that welcomes you to the meticulous setup for catering events, each visit feels personal and memorable. Don't miss their divine banana pudding for dessert, a must-have to round off your meal. Whether you dine in or order through DoorDash, prepare to be satisfied with oversized portions and a modest price point. Join the barbecue revolution at Old Carolina and taste the love in every bite!
OTHER SANDWICHES
Smokestack Burger
Hickory smoked for a unique flavor! 7oz Angus Beef Burger Patty Topped With Comeback Sauce, Pulled Pork, Creamy Coleslaw, Pickle Slices
Ranchero Dog
All beef Hot Dog topped with Pulled Pork, Fried onions and tangy Ranchero Sauce
Build Your Own Smoked Cheeseburger
7oz Angus Beef Burger Patty With Your Choice Of Toppings.
Smoked Ranchero Burger
7oz Angus Beef Burger Patty Topped With American Cheese, Fried Onion Straws, Sweet BBQ Sauce & Housemade Ranchero Sauce.
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
: Two Nashville Hot Chicken Tenders topped with Creamy Coleslaw, pickles and zesty Comeback Sauce on a toasted sandwich bun.
Cheesy Pete
All beef Hot Dog topped with Smokehouse Mac n Cheese, toasted breadcrumbs and Texas Pete Hot Sauce
Tar Heel Dog
All beef Hot Dog topped with Simply the World's Greatest Baked Beans and Creamy Coleslaw.
Classic 'Que Plate
6oz portion of smoked meat with one regular side & cornbread.
Pitmaster Special
Pulled Pork, Sliced Brisket, 2 Smoked Ribs with two regular sides, cornbread and a drink.
One Meat Platter (8oz)
8oz portion of smoked meat with two regular sides & cornbread.
Three Meat Platter (12oz)
Your choice of three meats, includes two regular sides and cornbread.
Two Meat Platter (10oz)
Your choice of two meats, includes two regular sides and cornbread.
The Ultimate Sampler
Ribs, Pulled Pork, Brisket, Pulled Chicken, Smoked Chicken Wings, two Sides and cornbread
BBQ PLATTERS
BBQ SAUCES & EXTRAS
Comeback Sauce Cup
Screamin' Beaver (Hot) Cup
Piedmont (Tangy) Cup
Original Gold (Mustard) Cup
Ranchero Sauce Cup
Original Classic (Sweet) Cup
Add An Extra Bun
Ranch Dressing Packet
Bottle Of BBQ Sauce
8 Ounce Cup Of BBQ Sauce
Pickles 2oz Cup
Pickles 8oz Cup
Kids Hot Dog Meal
Includes one Side and a Drink
Kids 2 Crispy Chicken Tenders Meal
12 and under only please. Includes Reg Side & Small Drink.
Kids Pulled Pork BBQ Mini Meal
12 and under only please. Includes Reg Side & Small Drink.
Kids Pulled Chicken BBQ Mini Meal
12 and under only please. Includes Reg Side & Small Drink.
KIDS MEALS
BOWLS & SALADS
BBQ Bowl
Mac-N-Cheese, French Fries or Mashed Potatoes, Onion Straws, Cheddar Cheese, BBQ Sauce and Green Onions with your Choice of Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken, Chopped Brisket or Chicken Tenders
Southwest True Q Salad
Greens. Fire Roasted Corn, Fried Onion Straws, Cheddar Cheese, Chicken (Pulled or Fried) & Zesty Ranchero Dressing.
Small BBQ Bowl
Mac-N-Cheese, French Fries or Mashed Potatoes, Onion Straws, Cheddar Cheese, BBQ Sauce and Green Onions with your Choice of Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken, Chopped Brisket or Chicken Tenders
Carolina House Salad
Greens, Carrots, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion, Cheddar Cheese & Cornbread Croutons. Full size served with one cornbread muffin.
Smoked Turkey Chef Salad
Smoked Turkey, Carrots, Cheddar Cheese, Cucumber, Egg, Red Onion, Tomatoes and Cornbread Croutons on a bed of Romaine Lettuce. Served with your choice of dressing and a cornbread muffin.
True Q Salad
Carolina House topped with: Pulled Pork, Chicken Breast, Pulled Chicken, Sliced Brisket or Fried Chicken Tenders.
Side Salad
Greens, Carrots, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion, Cheddar Cheese & Cornbread Croutons
Un-Sweet Tea
Banana Pudding
Rich, creamy and made in house every day!
Banana Pudding Cheesecake
Graham crust topped with creamy banana pudding-infused cheesecake and a layer of vanilla whipped topping.
1/2 Gallon Sweet Tea
1/2 Gallon Unsweet Tea
Soda
Sweet Tea
DRINKS & DESSERTS
BBQ SANDWICHES
Turkey Sandwich
Sliced Turkey Sandwich
2 BBQ Minis
Pork/Chicken or add 2 ea. for Brisket
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
Dry rubbed and slow smoked, served on a toasted bun
Chopped Brisket Sandwich
Chopped Brisket in a Beef Au Jus and served on a Toasted Bun
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood
Sliced Brisket Sandwich
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 12 hours over hickory wood
3 BBQ Minis
Pork/Chicken or add 2 ea. for Brisket
Two Sides
One Side
16 Oz Family Side
24 Oz Family Side
HOMESTYLE SIDES
FOUNDERS FAVORITES
Smoked Turkey Chef Salad
Smoked Turkey, Carrots, Cheddar Cheese, Cucumber, Egg, Red Onion, Tomatoes and Cornbread Croutons on a bed of Romaine Lettuce. Served with your choice of dressing and a cornbread muffin.
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Super tender and hand-pulled to order! Slow smoked daily over hickory wood for up to 14 hours.
Cheerwine Chocolate Bar
Smoked Ranchero Burger
7oz Angus Beef Burger Patty Topped With American Cheese, Fried Onion Straws, Sweet BBQ Sauce & Housemade Ranchero Sauce.
BBQ BOWL
Mac 'n Cheese, Mashed Potatoes or French Fries, Onion Straws, Cheddar Cheese, BBQ Sauce and Green Onions with your Choice of Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken, Chopped Brisket or Chicken Tenders.
Picnic Pack
Feeds 3-4: Choose One Meat, Two Small Family Sides, Choice of Bread and BBQ Sauce. Also included is One Slab of Ribs.
Large Family Dinner
Feeds 4-6: Choose Two Meats, Two Large Family Sides, Choice of Bread and BBQ Sauce
The Family Feast
Feeds 6-8: Choose Three Meats, Three Large Family Sides, Choice of Bread and BBQ Sauce
Large Family Side (24 Oz)
Small Family Dinner
Feeds 3-4: Choose One Meat, Two Small Family Sides, Choice of Bread and BBQ Sauce
Small Family Side (16 Oz)
FAMILY-STYLE MEALS
RIBS, WINGS & TENDERS
Full Slab Of Ribs
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 4.5 hours!
3 Jumbo Wing Sampler
Dry rubbed and slow smoked
10 Jumbo Wing Sampler
Dry rubbed and slow smoked
Third Slab Of Ribs
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 4.5 hours!
Half Slab Of Ribs
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 4.5 hours!
3 Crispy Chicken Tenders & Fries
3 Fresh. never-frozen, hand-breaded, jumbo crispy tenders
5 Jumbo Wing Sampler
Dry rubbed and slow smoked
One Dozen Buns
One Dozen Cornbread
Small Pan Party Pack
(Feeds 12) Includes a small pan of meat, 2 sides, buns and barbecue sauce
50 Wings
Small Pan Of Smoked Meats
(Feeds 12) Choose Your Meat and BBQ Sauce
Small Pan Of Sides
(Feeds 12) Choose Your Side